Aluminium Dummy Receivers. . .
Posted 03 September 2005 - 11:59 AM
I have a M1a1 Kit and a M1928a1 kit I want to build wall hangers out of. I wish I could have Doug Richarson Receivers on both of them, but with the wait and the money, I was thinking I would just get Phili Ordnance receivers instead. But I was thinking I can almost get both receivers in Aluminum for what the Phili '28 receiver costs.
What do you guys think?
Posted 03 September 2005 - 12:48 PM
Posted 06 September 2005 - 06:30 AM
The aluminum ones I have use a press fit for the barrel, they are not threaded. Swapped barrel, and now my new barrel does not fit anymore. It is not a good re-enactment prop when you swing it up and the barrel falls off.
Both my 1928 and M1 dummies have Phili Ord recievers. Not DR quality, but nice. See Deerslayer's post about the one he made into a finished gun, it looks pretty good!
Posted 07 September 2005 - 05:18 PM
Posted 07 September 2005 - 07:18 PM
Building a semi-auto from a Phil. Ord. receiver would be a daunting task.To start,BATFE would require you to build a closed bolt firing weapon,eliminating the use of your current bolt system. Also they do not like you to build a semi receiver to the same dimensions as the original full auto,to prevent easy conversion.
My advice would be to contact PK and/or Tommygunner.com(Damon) on this board to discuss using a Kahr 1927a1 along with your 1928a1 lower,butstock,and barrel($200 and ATF Form 1 required) to create a realistic legal Tommy.This has been done before Hopefully the board members that have had this done will chime in.
Posted 07 September 2005 - 07:43 PM
Posted 07 September 2005 - 08:17 PM
Posted 07 September 2005 - 08:44 PM
IMHO (and most others' humble opinions) your best bet for a semi-auto that looks correct would be to buy a semi-auto, file the Form 1, and then add the short bbl. once the Form 1 has been approved. In the end, you'll still come out cheaper than buying one of Kahr's SBR semi-autos, and much, much cheaper than trying to cobble up a semi-auto from an 80% receiver, parts kit (what few parts you'll be able to use), design trials, mill time, etc...
"Is the $200 tax a one time deal?" Yup. File it and forget it. The tax is only due by you once: upon either making or transfer. (Of course, if you later sell it as an SBR, the buyer will have to cough up for a tax stamp, just like you did when you made the SBR.)
One final caveat... before you go through the process of buying a semi-auto and a short bbl. be sure your state/local laws will allow you to possess an SBR (not all states allow them) and that even if your state/locality allows SBRs, be sure your CLEO will sign your Form 1. Without a CLEO sign-off and without your state permitting SBRs, the BATF will not approve the Form 1.
Posted 08 September 2005 - 12:29 AM
Posted 08 September 2005 - 08:02 PM
I think it is pretty much established that you have all kinds of legal problems in converting your Phil O. 80% receiver to be used as a semi. However, Doug Richardson used to make a semi 80% receiver, with the proper dimensions for use as a semi gun. There may be some of those still out there, so you could do some inquiries if building something from scratch appeals to you. The recommendations given here to go the semi-Kahr route is probably the most practical and economical way to achieve an authenic looking semi Thompson. I have one being built by Damon at Tommygunner, to be fitted with sbr, 28 frame, bolt hold-open modification, riveted lyman (original) and other features.
A savage actuator or no other kind of actuator will legally fit in a 80% receiver. Most peole with dummy guns have purchased the dummy screw in actuator knob, or fabricated their own. Maybe some of the board members will sell you one.
Posted 08 September 2005 - 11:15 PM
Posted 09 September 2005 - 06:07 AM
Doug made the engravings optional when he sold his receivers. However, most probably, a person putting out that much money would have had the engravings done also. As you probably know, Dougs operation has been on hold for a long time, so you may have to find existing ones.
Several people on this board sell the rivets. The supplier I'm aquainted with is Damon at Tommygunner. I believe our FAQ used to list suppliers' contact info. In case you weren't aware, riveting a Thompson sight is not an easy job, unless you have the equipment. I understand they have to be pressed on.
Posted 09 September 2005 - 06:49 AM
And no, it is not mine!
Price seems to be around market value. I don't remember what they (phili ord) want new, but I know they have a wait for them.